[文集] [专题] [检索] [独立评论] [海阔天空] [矛盾江湖] [全版论坛]


作者: WangYoucai   How did Li Shimin treat his brothers? 2025-04-05 08:26:45  [点击:6333]
ζԴļֵܵģ

Grok 3:

񣬼̫ڣйƳĵڶλʵۣڵǻ֮ǰ֮ͨ䡱ȡ˻λԴļֵܲȡ˹϶ĴʩҪֵܵĴʽ
1 ɣ̫ӣ
ԨijӣҲԭĻλ̳ˡΪ̫ӣڳӵй㷺֧֡ȻΪɶԼв62664գŷ䣬ʱɱɡʷأűɱ漴
2 Ԫ
ԪԨĵӣɽˣͬԿ֮УԪͬIJΧɱݡ顷أɱԪ䲿½Ԫ׼£־һвijײ
3 ֵ
◦ ԪԪȣֵܴδֱӲλᣬ֮δȻһЩֵı뷴й⵽ϴ磬Ԫں뷿Űı
◦ ԪࡢԪȣЩֵܽΪ͵δ񹹳в˵ԱȫǵӰϸơ
붯
ԴֵֶܵԴƳҵĻλսɺԪͼѹ񣬶ƾƽ񼽨¡սۣӵߵ֧֣Ȩ֮ȸԨλԼǻΪۣ׷ɡԪʵǶǵij׷񶨡
ʷ
ڵʱΪпᣬҲΪƳȶ춨˻λڼС֮ΡΪǽܳĵȻֵܵϴҲΪʷѧ۵Ľ㣬ΪζıȻѪ顣
ܽ˵֮ͨɱҪɺԪֵв̶ȲȡͬԣɱƣȷԼĻλȹ̡

DeepSeek:

̫ڣԴֵܵķʽƳȨΪͻ֮ͨ䡱ɡԪijͻǾ

### 1. **ɡԪļҶ**
- ****Ƴս׿̫ɡĵԪϣͼıݺͼ䲿ξٹ֪ڵȣ¶
- **֮䣨626꣩**ȷˣŷɱɡԪԨλԼǻΪۡһжζ֣ҲΪĽ㡣

### 2. **ֵõIJп**
- **ɱֶ**ɵӣееµȣԪӣԾ󻼡
- **Ů**ŮԼδǣɵ֣ԪϣΪɣԴ

### 3. **ֵܵİ**
- **ֵ**ԣԪԭͣδȨ
- **ֵ**ԪԪȣλΪϸȨֹγв羣Ԫıʱڣ

### 4. **ʷӰ**
- **ʷ**ٷʷ飨硶顷ͨǿ񱻱Σȥ߻ϸڡ۸ӣϿ֮εijɾͣҲС
- **Ų**ͨ޶ʷ顢ԭ̫Ӿɲκ磩ȷʽìܣͳΣչ˸߳

### 5. **ܽ᣺ȨȨ**
ֵֶܵηӳ˷⽨ȨIJпԡͨвҲעȶ֣ιɾͲֵ˵顣һ¼ΪйŴȨĵͰ

**ο**顷顷ͨʷء


ChatGPT:

Ƴĵڶλʵۣڼλ֮ǰͼλֵŸӵĹϵλĹСкֵܶܣмȽİɡԪڵȡ
1. ɣij֣Ϊ̫ӡɹͬ񣬵ԸIJͬ𽥲ìܡΪԼǿҳȨ⵼ֵ֮ľգڡ֮䡱У񷢶䣬ɹɱɺԪҪľ֣ΪԼǻΪɨϰ
2. ԪԪɵĵܵܣҲһλֵܡһ𷴶Ȩš֮УԪҲɱΪԼĵλۣ֮Ȼ˾ٲпᣬΪΪ˹ҵȶԼߵ룬DZҪġ
3. ڣһλֵܣʷû̫顣ȻнϸߵελĹϵԽϺãûвλᡣڳΪʵۺҲڽΪɵĴûйԤѡ

ܽ˵ڶԴֵܵĹУλĹУȡ˷dzϺֶΡΪʵԼĿ꣬ϧɱλҪ֡ɺԪֵԿݡ

Gemini:

Դļֵܣر̫ɺԪȡ˽ȻֶͬΣյˡ֮䡱Ƕһ¼ϸ
ڹϵţ
* Ƴսպգܸߣʹ̫ɺԪев
* ֵ֮ìǸԽᵳӪ˽λ̳Ȩ
* ɡԪ֮ì漤յˡ֮䡱
֮䣺
* Ԫ626꣬ŷ䣬ɱɺԪ
* ¼ƳʷϵҪת۵㣬˵ǻΪۣʷ̫ڡ

* ǻ󣬶ֵܼȡԿݵ̬ȡ
* δֵܵĺдģɱ¾ǾܵظһĹְͷ͡
* ֮ǰֵµһЩ˲ţҲһ£Ҹá
ʷۣ
* ֮䡱йʷ¼Ҳ˴顣
* һЩΪΪȡλֶΣҲΪΪάȶȲȡж
* ΣͳΪƳķٵ춨˻ġ֮ΡҲΪйʷϵʢ
ܵ˵Դֵ̬ܵǸӵģвпһ棬Ҳпݵһ档ΪӰƳʷ


Claude:

Դֵ̬ܵйʷξ¼ҪƳڡ

ƸԨĴӣ֮дֵܹϵķʽΪ

1. ̫ɣϵŲ֮(626)ɱΪճǻλĵһ̳ˣΪζ֡

2. ĵԪ()֮ͬбɱԪɽˣ˹ͬԿ

3. ԪԣݴԪţǻǰȥ

4. ֵܣԪܲԪȣǻʣֵܶзеıᣬеıԾ

֮ʹԨλԼǻΪ̫ڡȻĶλֶμΪңλڼ䴴"֮"ʢΪйʷ

ʷѧձΪֵܵĴ÷ӳ˹ŴȨIJпԣԼ"յܼ""ճӼ̳"ּ̳йijͻ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Perplexity:

̫Դֵܵķʽ˸ԣȨֵΪԡ
֮
Ԫ62672գŷ䣬ɱɺĵԪȡλⳡԴֵܼȨΪɺԪԼвDzȡȷˡ
ֵõĴ
ɺԪĴ󲿷ֺһЩֶŮЩŮԶԻλûвѡƴǣԻ۹.
ֵ̬ܵ
ֵܽãȡ˽Ϊݵ̬ȡֵܱΪطԱЭȹƳͳ.
ȨʱֳϺ飬ڹȨ󣬶вչԿݵһ档

Grok3 :

Here is the English translation of the previous response:

How did Li Shimin treat his brothers?
Li Shimin, also known as Emperor Taizong of Tang, was the second emperor of the Tang Dynasty in China. Before ascending to the throne, he seized power through the Xuanwu Gate Incident and dealt with his brothers in a decisive and harsh manner. Below is how he handled his main brothers:
1 Li Jiancheng (Crown Prince)
Li Jiancheng, the eldest son of Emperor Gaozu (Li Yuan), was the designated heir to the throne. As the crown prince, he had widespread support in the court. However, Li Shimin viewed him as a threat. On June 4, 626, Li Shimin launched a coup at Xuanwu Gate, personally leading troops to ambush and kill Li Jiancheng. Historical records state that Li Jiancheng was shot dead at Xuanwu Gate, and his faction was subsequently eliminated.
2 Li Yuanji (Prince of Qi)
Li Yuanji, the fourth son of Li Yuan, allied with Li Jiancheng to oppose Li Shimin. During the Xuanwu Gate Incident, Li Yuanji was also surrounded and killed by Li Shimins forces. According to the Old Book of Tang, Li Shimin personally shot Li Yuanji, and his head was later severed by Li Shimins subordinates, marking the complete removal of this threat.
3 Other Brothers
◦ Li Yuanjing, Li Yuanchang, etc.: Most of Li Shimins other brothers did not directly participate in the struggle for the throne and thus were not immediately executed after the Xuanwu Gate Incident. However, some were later purged for alleged involvement in rebellions or connections to opposing factions. For example, Li Yuanchang was forced to commit suicide after being implicated in a later conspiracy led by Fang Yiai.
◦ Li Yuanheng, Li Yuangui, etc.: These brothers kept a low profile and posed no significant threat to Li Shimin. As a result, they were spared but had their political influence strictly curtailed.
Background and Motives
Li Shimins harsh treatment of his brothers stemmed from the intense power struggle in the early Tang Dynasty. Li Jiancheng and Li Yuanji had teamed up to suppress Li Shimin, who, bolstered by his military achievements (such as defeating Dou Jiande and Wang Shichong) and the support of his followers, gradually gained the upper hand. After the Xuanwu Gate Incident, Li Shimin forced his father, Li Yuan, to abdicate, ascended the throne, and posthumously honored Li Jiancheng and Li Yuanjithough this was effectively a symbolic gesture to negate their legacy.
Historical Evaluation
Li Shimins actions were seen as ruthless at the time, but they laid the foundation for the Tang Dynastys stability. During his reign, he ushered in the Zhenguan Era, a period of prosperity widely regarded as a golden age, earning him praise as an exceptional emperor. However, his purge of his brothers remains a point of contention among historians. Some view it as an inevitable outcome of political struggle, while others criticize it as cold-blooded and merciless.
In summary, Li Shimin killed his primary rivals, Li Jiancheng and Li Yuanji, during the Xuanwu Gate Incident and dealt with his other brothers based on the level of threat they posedeither executing them or keeping them under controlto secure his throne.
���༭ʱ��: 2025-04-05 08:28:41

加跟贴

笔名:     新网友请先注册笔名 密码:
主题: 进文集
内容: